Signed in as:
filler@godaddy.com
Classic taste. We don't measure our vanilla.
Fresh raspberries and white chocolate flavors. Mud cakes are a dense, brownie styled cake.
Browned butter & sugars for a caramelized brownie/cake hybrid mudcake
Everyone loves sprinkles!
Made from locally farmed Strawberries, no artificial flavorings.
Made from raw cacao for a rich flavor
Dark chocolate cake with Sweet Cherries
Lightly sweet and brightly flavored from fresh lemon zest & home made buttermilk.
Is it chocolate? Is it vanilla?
A lemon flavored sponge with fresh blueberries throughout.
Made with fresh carrots
A classic sponge with the fall favorite spices.
Vanilla Sponge with hints of amaretto
a fluffy white sponge cake with sweetened shredded coconut
butter cake with chopped pecans
A vanilla cake based with crushed pistachios.
cinnamon sugar infused vanilla cake
made with fresh orange zest and juice
Deliciously moist banana cake with semi-sweet chocolate chips
vanilla based cake with crushed oreos & chocolate chip cookie crumbles
For Cakes & Cupcakes
A sweet, classic frosting.
A decadent frosting made from free trade cacao
Yummy vanilla buttercream with crushed chocolate cookies.
Fan favorite! Our secret recipe that's so good, you will think you're eating straight from the tub.
Creamy & lightly sweetened
Vanilla frosting and rainbow sprinkles.
Rich and creamy frosting made from freshly ground peanut butter & cocoa.
Made with real strawberries, no flavorings.
Made from brown sugar, coconut and pecans, this recipe is delicious as a filling or topping.
Delicious & creamy with a white chocolate base.
locally sourced Twin Falls honey
naturally flavored with lemon zest
sweetened with house made butterscotch
housemade marshmellow fluff, crushed graham crackers and chocolate chips
Raspberry, Strawberry, Blueberry or Lemon Curd
Please be advised that baked goods may contain or come into contact with peanuts, tree nuts or other allergens.
Idaho Trademarked & Copyrighted © 2026 Batter Up Bakery - All Rights Reserved. Twin Falls, Idaho • Serving the Magic Valley

Everything is made to order, we do not offer pre-made cakes. We are not a storefront; we are a licensed private kitchen available for delivery or pickup.